Fairway Market Reviews

Horrible app; Constant glitches, freezes and inability to load digital coupons. Not worth downloading FairwayMarket until major updates and improvements are made.

It’s not showing the points I’m earning when I make purchases.

FairwayMarket is riddled with bugs and reproducibly fails when attempting to perform it’s most basic and important tasks. For example, FairwayMarket persistently fails to add a barcoded card to Apple Wallet, showing users a completely unhelpful message reading “ Sorry, there was a problem when trying to create the wallet pass. Try again later.” This is just one example of FairwayMarket ’s poor user experience.

Developers, please fix these show-stopping bugs!

Much much much worse. We need a new market in the area. I wish West Side Market would come back.

Poor customer service. Quality of prepared food has plummeted. It’s seriously gone downhill to the point where I rarely even go in. A shadow of its former self. Sad.

I downloaded FairwayMarket 2 weeks ago and I have to say that I’m very disappointed with it. The advertised digital coupons are not available for download...which is very frustrating. Also, when I try to access different features (i.e circular or create a shopping list) I get an error message: “bad request”. Fix FairwayMarket!!

The check box to save login won’t check, so you have to relogin every time you open FairwayMarket .

Tried clicked on shop online from shopping list and nothing happened. Have tried every thing and still can’t figure this site out. From weekly specials to insider pricing. I’ve given up

Every time I try to create an account it says it's sending a verification email but it nevers comes. If you don't have an email and password to log in you can't use any of the features like digital coupons.

The website does not permit turning 90 degrees so that it can be better seen when in a horizontal position.

As of May 2026; The 86th store is only user friendly if provoked. No smiley faces. Sad sacks. Many of the handlers especially in the vegetable section speak little or no english. Mis-market or scrambled price tags abound. Such as fruit piled so you can’t read the tags (or can’t find them). Items disappear without notice or explanation (such as fresh orange juice). Jerome a store wandering helper is a gem! Otherwise this place needs a top to bottom reorganization!

This web interface is very confusing.

Prices significantly increased, above general inflation bump. Website unusable. When Fairway announced move to 86th Street excitement was high, shopped here happily until bought by Shoprite (better prices and service at suburban stores), prices slowly and steadily increased. A reasonable business model perhaps, but I’m not so time pressed, financially sloppy and lacking in options as to make anything but small purchases here when convenience dictates.

See above

Ever since Fairway was bought, I have noticed that the scope of product choices has been diminished. The cheese selection is smaller, the meat selection is more limited and the deli shelves look like they have been cut in half.
It would be nice to see some of the food choices return and the service to be more available. This was my neighborhood store for over 20 years. I may be forced to go to other places like Zabars for cheese, Citarellas for meat and Whole Foods for other products. We now have other neighborhood options. Fairway should reconsider its plans going forward.

It’s a really good app but occasionally you have delete it and reinstall it in order to get it to work again

Great values just get better!

The weekly circular is an excellent source of information and an excellent guide as well. At a time when the economy is both unpredictable and unstable it is good to know that Fairway maintains prices at the “affordable” end without sacrificing choice.

Super helpful & kind

Always enjoy looking at the circular before I shop and make my list. Thank you for making my life easier.