Brian's Toys: Sell My Toys Reviews

Brian s Toys Reviews

Published by on 2025-11-13

🏷️ About: Are you looking to sell your collection of modern toys? Not looking to waste your time listing them one by one on eBay? The Sell My Toys® app from Brian’s Toys makes this process quick and easy for you! Just scan your barcodes and get quotes for your collection with Sell My Toys®! Create and manage lists of your toy collection by scanning the bar codes on the packaging of your modern toys. Submit this list to Brian’s T.


       


Is Brian s Toys Safe to Use?

We Investigate the app owner's website (Brianstoys.com), verify their legitimacy, and uncover hidden scams and complaints.


Overall Customer Experience 😎


😎 Positive experience
66.6%

🤬 Negative experience
33.4%

🫥 Neutral
0.0%

~ from Justuseapp.com NLP analysis of 556 combined software reviews.

Is Brian s Toys Safe?
Brian's Toys: Sell My Toys is very safe to use.
66.6/100

  Safety Analysis »»

Is Brian s Toys Legit?
Brian's Toys: Sell My Toys looks authentic and legitimate.
66.6/100



Read 20 Customer Service Reviews 😠💢

4.6 out of 5
To say insulted would be a massive understatement!

I got sick of my 1993 power rangers sitting on a shelf untouched for way too long. I can blame myself thinking not everyone is out to rob you. It’s been years since I checked online for an updated price, but I figured I’d try it out for fun. I got an $85 quote for an item that I knew was worth much more and since I wasn’t in a hurry I considered it. Until I got a message less than a day later saying they gave me the wrong buy price and re-quoted $20 or $25 dollars instead. I thought for $60 less I’d take 2 minutes to look it up. $400 for mint like mine and $300 for used. I know these are long shot prices, but if just one person considers it something they just need than why not? $85 was pushing it, but $25? Thank you for reassuring me that there are still plenty of people out there waiting to take advantage of others. Sorry! Not this time! They really need to start allowing zero stars when it’s called for.

Not really a tool for casual collectors

If you’re a serious/money collector, BriansToys is not for you.

While it is a neat and clever idea, these people have zero intentions on paying fair prices for legitimate collectibles.

To begin with, their database doesn’t seem to be too expansive yet. I won’t give them a hard time for that because everyone has to start somewhere- and like I said, this is a neat idea, in theory.

I am serious collector of Funko pops. I have paid rent with the money I’ve made with these things at times. I know a thing or two about them. I have an expansive collection but it took me a while to scan something that was actually found on BriansToys. I took a big money item and scanned it only to get back a $6 quote. Uh uh. Nice try, Stephen Frye.

So it was a nice thing to check out but I’ll delete BriansToys and keep on truckin’ with my old world ways of actually speaking to people and haggling and dealing… like a man… with chest hair!

Not Worth It

Went through scanning, submitting list, and getting an offer. The scanning part of BriansToys stopped working after 60 or so items. Later tried scanning other items, got 21 onto a different list. Most prices received were under 5% of eBay values for the same sold items on eBay. Sorted through my items for the toys with offers and boxed them, weighed boxes. Shipping is discounted by more than 50%, but after deducting that cost from the total offered, it was not worth the net I would have been paid. Brian’s Toys says they are “strict” with their grading, so although my toy collection is quite collectible, still new in boxes after 30 plus years, and easily saleable, there is no information about their grading process, so you may not get the price they offered in the first place. I will keep my collection and sell piecemeal on eBay or elsewhere as selling just two of the items there that they wanted to buy will net more money than the net price that I would have received from Brian’s Toys, and with far less hassle. My advice is to skip using BriansToys and Brian’s Toys completely.

They’re great!

Only prices on the more bigger or value able “Funkopop!” Could. Really see better prices just saying a 10” shenron is. Not! Worth 4$ but. Hey what options do we have if we’re getting Todd’s them, so again I give thanks n respect their choices. Thanks for helping and taking my “bulk common pops” you really help clear the clutter,see yours again soon good experience. Guys. Thanks so much.

Awesome to use

I had no problems downloading BriansToys and using it. Very straight forward and easy to use. The customer service is awesome and got back to me with a few days of each question and inquiry. Most of the negative comments on here are because most of these people want “retail” pricing for their items. Then don’t realize that the company needs to make a little something as well. Also what they THINK the item is worth is NOT actually what it is worth. Good rule of thumb here is, your item is only worth what someone is willing to pay for it. Have a bunch more stuff I will be scanning with them. JUST AN AWESOME EXPERIENCE!!!!!! Thank you Brian’s Toys!

Scan and submit for sell

Easy process, easily scan your barcode and get a price quote. Even if barcode doesn’t register they provide the correct info and still give you a quote for purchasing your items.

Quick and easy

App is easy to use and selling couldn’t be easier. When I submitted my list they got back to me in a few hours. Made the process very simple.

Excellent service

Brian was really great to work with. I messed up my first list and he told me how to fix it. He responded very quickly to my emails and list.

I would highly recommend his sight if you are interested in selling toys.

Great team and app to do business with

Super easy to use and submit. They are also easy to work with giving me a fair price for all my items and paying me quickly for them.

Very cool way to sell

Makes it way easier to search and sell toys without having to tote them all over the place to different stores to see who or what is interested in buying them.

Dolls

I’m not getting as much as I hoped for but it turns out a lot of Barbie’s we thought would be worth something one day just aren’t. That’s ok. It’s money I didn’t have in my pocket and I’m freeing up some space. Would definitely recommend.

First Choice to sell Barbies

Brian’s should be your first and only choice when it comes to selling your items. The scanner from BriansToys is by far the easiest to use. I actually sent my list to another company and their bid was $1000 less than Brian’s! The customer service was by far the best. Michael walked me through every step of the process. Thank you Brian’s Toys!

Beyond Easy!!

I was contemplating for months how to move my whole Star Wars figure collection. Brian’s Toys app was super simple. Scan, verify, and get quote. Ran into a couple items that were not showing up. Easy and quick communication via email and was resolved with in minutes. Life changer indeed.

Easiest and Best Ever

I was a little skeptical at first because the process was just was too easy. But…this is a legit app and team. After receiving my quote, the finalization, shipping and payment was within a few days. It was too easy that I even called to speak with them to make sure I was doing it correct and they were so friendly and professional to assure me.

A app that works

I’m trying to sell a Barbie hopefully. We will be sending more . Cause those things are everywhere. She is kinda getting to be annoying. I had to send one cause mom doesn’t trust them. BriansToys worked like it’s supposed to and eased my mind a bunch. It scanned quick . Brought up info quick . I did didn’t try if the rarer as well as regular could be told with a scan.
It’s gone so smoothly so far see

Talk about above and beyond…..

To say Brian’s Toys is great and provides outstanding customer service is an absolute understatement!! I was so pleased with my phone interaction that I couldn’t help but to just sit and think about how well put together and thought out this company is. I would recommend this business 10/10 every single time, hands down. Thank you guys. I really appreciate the time and effort you put in to helping me with my toy selling questions and needs!

Easy to use app, excellent service

Twice I have sold a large quantity of dolls to this site. BriansToys was very easy to use and made communicating about my items simple. Once I scanned my items, the customer service was top-notch. I had researched prices before my sale and found their offers to be competitive. The staff was friendly and quickly responded to all my questions. I was most nervous about shipping such a large quantity but that too was made easy by Brian's Toys. I highly recommend BriansToys for anyone looking to sell toys.

Brian’s Toys made the decision easy

When my mother asked me to find a venue to help sell her small toy collection, I didn’t know where to begin. A few Google searches in, I found Brian’s Toys. Their video on ‘this is how we do it’ was encouraging. After a few pictures and a couple of emails- we had an offer that was more that we expected. The process was easy and mom was very happy with the offer. We’ll have to see what other toys are hiding in closets and do this again. Thank you Brian’s toys for making this an easy task fruitfully completed!

Great experience

Using BriansToys to scan approximately 100 barbies worked very well. I did have about 10 that didn’t scan & required additional assistance from Brian’s toys.
After pondering if I really wanted to sell my collection, and excellent customer service & communication from Travis, I boxed up my dolls & sent them on their way.
About a week went by for delivery & product review. But as soon as they were reviewed, Travis was in touch & our transaction was complete. Paid in full as agreed upon.
Thank you to Brian’s toys for taking the time consuming task of individually selling my dolls, off my plate.

Great company

These guys are great! I’ve sold to and bought from this company a number of times and I’ve always had a very pleasant and professional experience! Highly recommended! 🤙



Is Brian s Toys Safe? 🙏

Brian's Toys: Sell My Toys is very safe to use. JustUseApp Safety Score for Brian s Toys is 66.6/100.
This assessment is based on our NLP analysis of 556 user reviews. Combined with the app store average rating of 4.6/5.

Safety Analysis

80.5% of users say app is safe 👍
80.5%

11.9% of users have some concerns ⚠️
11.9%

7.6% of users say app is risky 🚨
7.6%


Is Brian s Toys Legit? 💯

Brian's Toys: Sell My Toys looks authentic and legitimate. Our NLP models processed user feedback to estimate legitimacy. JustUseApp Legitimacy Score for Brian s Toys is 66.6/100 .
This conclusion is based on analysis of 556 user reviews.

🔏 Privacy & Data Safety

Brian s Toys collected the following data from you:

  • Data Used to Track You:
    • Identifiers
    • Usage Data
  • Data Not Linked to You:
    • Identifiers
    • Usage Data



How was your experience with Brian's Toys: Sell My Toys? Post a Review




Features

Star Wars, Marvel Toys, Vintage Toys, Action Figures, Star Wars Toys, Barbie Dolls, Old Toys, My Funko Pops, Action Figure Collector, Star Wars Sell, Funko Pop.

Just scan your barcodes and get quotes for your collection with Sell My Toys®! Create and manage lists of your toy collection by scanning the bar codes on the packaging of your modern toys.

If you have vintage figures from 1980s or earlier, you will need to e=mail pictures to [email protected]. Prices for vintage items depend heavily on condition.

We buy Star Wars, Barbie, Marvel, LEGO, GI Joe, and many more toy lines.

Submit this list to Brian’s Toys to receive an offer.

  Contact Support
Developer:
Brian's Toys, Inc.


Website:

Privacy Policy: