Idle Eleven Reviews

I don’t usually write reviews for games but I just had to on this one. I had so much fun playing it until I couldn’t play until the next day. I feel like it just ruins the game how little you are allowed to play it. Secondly, I have diamond star players that only have a 39% chance of scoring! Like, come on you can do better than that. Also, I could be 2 entire overall points better than the other team and have 10 chances to there 2 and I would still lose the game 2-0. I only know that I’ll win if I’m worse than the other team. I being serious when I say that whenever I am the worse overall team by however many points, I still somehow win. Please fix your game.

I have never written a review on an app before but this is a start! I enjoyed the game but slowly I started to get very frustrated because It was slowly coming to me that.. maybe your overall and your diamond stars don’t mean anything! I would spend hours saving up, leveling up and swapping out players just so I can beat the next players team. I would have better players and better overall and either lose or tie. It wasn’t making sense.

Another thing was the shooting... like how and why did players miss? Was it because we didn’t level up their “shooting” as much as other players? How was my Striker at 5 diamond stars only having a 39% chance of getting a goal compared to a 5 star silver player and then MISSING??? Or how was a gold star scoring against my diamond star goalie??

It all doesn’t make sense and there’s honestly no pattern... so it’s like you don’t even feel rewarded for your hard work. Once the developers can answer this question I will install the game again and try again and if all is fixed, I will update my ratings to 5 stars.

Alright look let’s go straight to the point your game is fun some things you should add and remove look ok the first thing is that you need to remove the three to four games per day feature like come one then the worst thing you tell us to train our players until the next day? That’s dumb fix that and we need subs I hate losing players that were so good for my team ok I want a feature where you have subs and you have an option to sell them for some amount of money ok two maybe a quick multiplayer nothing crazy ok and the other thing I hate about this game if you leave for a few days or weeks you will see that you have lost over five or six matches in a row like your commanding us to play your game like you telling us that if you don’t play our game we will make you lost a ton of matches and you will be in last position like nooo that isn’t cool at all remove that feature pls you know let me tell you that feature is the one that made your game lose popularity so if you don’t want it to go down REMOVE THAT ANNOYING FEATURE!

Sorry if I made it a little bit harsh but it’s my honest opinion your game has some potential so pls fix the problems and stop typing to people that do a bad review on your game show some love to people that also appericiate and play this game 24/7 like y’all are being proud buy either way I like the game

It is so dumb that the striker and defender will have basically the same chance of scoring in a game. I understand, because Not every chance will be a easy goal scoring opportunity. I believe the chance of your players scoring is all based on luck. Improving your prayers stats gives you the EXACT same percentage chances. It’s also dumb how when I’m in a division match and I just decide to not play a match and level up my team, somehow the other teams level up too? There is no reward for leveling up your players. I’m not sure the developers even watch football.

Most reviews say they see potential in this game but have small complaints. And the developers have the same auto generated response each time, and responding that they will take the review into consideration and thank the reviewer for leaving feedback. They still have yet to fix the most popular criticism being that you have a limit to the amount of games you can play. I feel like they would at least have a subscription or vip edition that lets you play as many as you want but no. And I saw another review where they asked for a bench/reserve for your club legends or “super subs” off the bench which would be a cool feature. And it would be a cool feature if you could sell your players or loan your players like in real life. The only reason I’m making this review is because I used to play the game a long time ago and it feels like nothings changed so please actually take the reviews into consideration.:)

I’m just starting out, my team average is 30.5 and my star is a 31, striker with 4 gold stars. He seldom gets shots and when he’s wide open and you select him to shoot he has 30% chance of scoring. The rest of my team is level 30 with one platinum star and I’m constantly getting beat by teams with average 27 and their scorers are 27, with 4 bronze stars. How can my level 30 platinum defense and goalie not stop them?!?
I’ll keep play, it passes the time, just don’t get frustrated when you lose and shouldn’t. It seems like there’s no real point in getting higher caliber players, so save your money and just max out your wimpy players.

This game was fun when I first started, upgrading your player, gradually increasing your team value, but there is one problem. playing the matches in this game, when I am at a scoring opportunity I pick my 22 rated multi gold star attacking mid and I am given a 38% chance of scoring and frequently do not score. While the opponent scores with their 21 rated multi bronze star center back on their few opportunities to score. Why does this happen?

I don’t write reviews but I enjoy the concept behind this game, thus the 3 stars rather than 1. However, my complaint is how unbalanced it is. As previous reviews have stated, what’s the point in upgrading and spending all this time if it doesn’t matter. I’ve lost more games than I’ve won to teams considerably lower than me. I understand “can’t win 100% of the time” but there needs to be some serious balance that makes all the time spent actually worth it. No reason for my platinum star GK getting scored on by a player 2 levels lower with 1 bronze star.

I love the concept of this game - I really do- but that being said, I really dislike the chance you get when on a goalscoring opportunity. The tutorial tells you to “Choose wisely”, so I choose the most logical player.. either a forward or midfielder, but guess what? I get hit with 35%, 40%, 55%, rarely do I see a 75% or 60%… I’m very unsure on what determines your goalscoring chances. Other than that, it’s a good time waster, it’s a fun game to have in your pocket and to just whip out and spend a couple minutes on. I really enjoy the concept, and it’s satisfying building up your squad.

I was hooked on the game it felt awesome.
BUT that changed when I came to know it’s just bots that I’m playing against and that everyone can be top spot on the divisions. Also the players cost wayyyyyy to much compared to what you get for upgrading once you get past 33-35 it’s absurd and there’s no actual rewards for going higher in the leagues apart from income boost which stopped for me at 15x which was the 3rd income boost idk if it goes higher form that because the player costs sure get higher so idk why the boost can’t.

I just got a new phone and I started playing this game. I like this game but I would love to see if you can have 22 players in the roster.

The problem is I played this game for like 5-8 minutes and I keep feeling my phone overheating. I was wondering why my phone is overheating so maybe it is the game? But after I finished the playing game, my phone battery was 100% and it’s used the battery up and then it was 85%. So why IdleEleven takes up my battery so much? I think IdleEleven needs to improve on the battery life.

Overall, I like the game and again, I would love to see a lot of improvements!

I find this game to be extremely fun. It has a great idle tycoon concept while still being very interactive.

The one problem that I am continuing to have on a regular basis is the game crashing constantly. I find myself in the middle of doing anything to just see the game freeze or the screen turn black. This makes me reload the game which already takes longer than I would prefer. One other problem I have is that when playing a game, there should be a button or an option that allows you to skip to the next chance or make the speed of the game go faster. For example a 1.5x speed or a 2x speed etc.I would also like a button you can just press to skip to the next chance.

Overall, I feel this is a great game that just needs a few fixes in the way it runs and how it works.

So I started playing this game and was given the star player Kalvin Philipp for free which was nice. Then as I progressed I saw Xavi Simmon and Cristian Ronaldo which I eventually added to my team after many ads. That was when my team overall was 30 and 40. I’ve restarted my club and worked all the way to the top league Pantheon hoping that more of these “Special Players” would show up in the transfer market but they never did. I really wanted to see Messi and Mbappe and other “Special Players” but non ever showed and there isn’t a clear answer to collecting and adding more of these players to your team. You gave a list of all the types of special players yet I have only seen 3 out of the 5 you say there are. So I now ask, how can I get more of these players on my team and why won’t they show up in the transfer market?

Why can you only play a certain amount of games per day to me it makes me get unhooked from it when I wanna play it because I wanna be able to play more and also do more faster, the only other problem is how sometimes I have my 28 rated striker misses against 24 defense and only has 37% chance with 2 sliver stars meanwhile they score and draw on my 27 rated 2 sliver stars goalie while they score with 2 star bronze that’s 24 rated

Why is there a limit to how many games you can play?? The game is so fun but I play 3 matches then I have to wait until tomorrow. That’s super questionable not gonna lie! You guys should change this feature or at least make it so you have to buy it. It makes it so much less enjoyable. Hope you read this but you guys have an awesome game, just a few things I would change.

Best of wishes,
Rahul

First things first: Don’t be a cheapskate, pony up the $5 for the VIP experience. You’ll get a lot more from this, including more control over how often you see ads.

Now the part that matters: At its heart, Idle Eleven is football management for people who don’t like football management. Gaining money for your club is as easy as swiping, and the transfer window never closes so there’s always a chance to recruit the next big star for your team. You can also improve your existing roster by training players, and sometimes you have to choose between training and hitting the transfer market.

There are actual matches to be had here, too. You don’t do much in them save for choosing who takes the chance in a goal opportunity, but taking part in the matches also helps gain money for your club so it pays to attend them. The better your team, the better your odds…but just as in real life, the team that’s favored does not always win.

With plenty of leagues to conquer and the ability to start taking over a new side with your upgrades intact, there’s plenty of idle replay value to be had here. Fans of the Football Manager series might want to stay away, but for everybody else this is your chance to establish that maybe you can be the competent football manager you always thought you could be. Recommended!

Idle eleven is a great, fun game, but some aspects could definitely be improved. For example you start your team with everyone being 21 overall, This is Super low. Each time you level up it increases by one. In my opinion it would be more realistic to use a EA/FIFA based rating system. I say this because most of the fanbase from this game definitely knows and has a high chance of playing EA FIFA. And is familiar with their system.

Overall great game, if you decide to download it definitely shell out the 5 dollars for premium, its worth it.

The game is very entertaining. Good for wasting time, I play it on my flights all the time or at home while I’m doing something in the computer. The only things that I can suggest is there being an option to skip the animation for when your player upgrades in star tier. I’d prefer to just upgrade without having to stop and waiting for the animation to go away. Also teams shouldn’t get better drastically. Before I went to bed the team I was set to play the next day was around 50 rating and I had ranked up my players up to 90 and the next morning the opponent was just about the same rating. Make it make sense but again as I said very fun game!

I never write reviews but I’m doing this because this game is so fun. This game is easy and it’s a offline game so it’s a great game for long car rides. This is the best game is the best game that I’ve had in a while. The bad part about this game is that you only get 3 rounds to play without VIP and VIP is $10 dollars I think they should lower it to $5 or $7 dollars.

So I love the game as a whole. It’s so much fun. I’ve been completely hooked. My only complaint is that you can only play 3 season games in a day. Which is a little annoying. If you could make it where you have energy points you spend on games and it replenishes after a certain amount of time, I would consider that a lot better. Everything else is pretty fun.

I’m hoping in the future you come up with an American Football, and Hockey one. Because these games are engaging and fun!