Astonishing Baseball Manager Reviews

Was loving this gm game and put a ton of time into it. But the game becomes unfair once you win a couple championships. At that point a “rival gm” enters the game and the games gives them all legendary players. Making them unbeatable, they GM has now won 10 straight championships in my league with no sign of slowing down. The second they lose a legendary player another on is on their roster. The only chance you’ll have to pay a ton of money to match their legendary players.

I’d happily pay for a pay version of the game instead of the current pay to play version they have.

Don’t get me wrong, it’s a fantastic game with great features, player development and various things to do. But it lacks in consistency when it comes to simulated stats and it’s borderline impossible to win any accolade (even if you are the best team in the league by over 10 wins and you have a pitcher go undefeated with 17 wins…) Overall, great game but needs some tuning up

I played the game it was pretty fun and I spent money on a legend 20m payroll and I also got god mode…which I didn’t use because I wanted the more entertaining experience, so I had played a couple of seasons like 4 or 5 seasons when I went to sleep and a family member deleted the game, when I re downloaded it I found that I had no progress I was frustrated I couldn’t find an option to open the save, but then I was ahh no worries ill start a new game and just restore purchases at least….NOTHING… I literally have the purchases being charged right now and I don’t have them in the game please give me some help on this.

I really love this game been playing it since high school every version it’s starting to get to the point where it’s easy to win I remember the days where I would think I built a gold team and would lose other teams pitching and roster management can be bad at times

If you love building a baseball team as a coach and general manager then this game is for you!! You can set the game to be as challenging as you want. Draft your team, buy your team, develop your team through prospects….you decide the road to your dynasty. Give the game a try and you won’t put it down.

This is probably one of the best baseball sims out, but I have one issue. I feel like it’s a stat driven game, yet theres no way to see more in-depth stat history to get a baseline. I have a franchise that’s ran for over 90 years, and it would be nice to see team stat history, player history and a more in-depth all time leaders and all time team leaderboards. The current choice is a small list in the hall of fame, and it’s doesn’t update properly. Other than that, the game is great, but I feel like its lacking in that sense

Could easily be 5 stars but it’s way too similar to last years game now. I understand you need time to update, but this game is way behind ABK and they had more time to develop since the lockout. I’m still waiting to play “My Franchise Player” but for some reason that’s not an addition. Still great game but besides the new things in the stadium and menu, you may as well play last years.
Really hope you guys update soon! Because I know I’m not the only one who is close to not playing it.

Enjoy the game but after my first few season I realized that the training points I negotiated with the team after a season wasn’t adding up correctly I felt discouraged to continue with multiple seasons so after somewhere between 8-12 seasons I’m going to have to stop playing as I don’t feel I’m progressing proficiently

I would give this 5 stars. I think this is an amazing game and I love to play it on road trips to past the time. However, one thing annoys me. Whenever I do “my player” mode and I do great my rookie season, like a 300 average, when I check my stats (career stats) it says I have a 184 average and has more at bats than I had for my rookie season. Does anyone know why this happens?

This is one, if not the best baseball sim on AstonishingBaseballManager Store. I love how they create a template new article after every game so even if you sim
The games you can understand what’s going on. The only thing I would change is somehow showing a players overall and easier lineup created/editor. The overall is just based on there stats, which can fluctuate, and the lineup is a bit hard to make work quickly. You kinda just have to move your players around for a bit. Other than those problem that probably only affect me I think the game is wonderful

If you are looking for a manager sim but don’t want to pay for out of the park baseball then this is it. There is a lot that you are able to do but it is welcoming to people who don’t understand some aspects of baseball. It’s quite addicting and is a lot of fun

This is, without a doubt, the baseball sim that I’ve played in a long while. So fun and addictive! It’s great that you can play at your own pace. Highly recommend to anyone interested in baseball sim management type games!

So far it’s been great and I don’t really have any complaints, I would like the ability to respond to people sending messages in the inbox and post my own social media post but other than that the game is great

When it comes to baseball sims for mobile, it only takes a few minutes of playtime to recognize AstonishingBaseballManager as the best there is.
Lots of fun and intuitively ways to lead a baseball franchise that have measurable impact on the team being lead.
Great game and I am excited to play more.

I have to say that this game is my favorite on my device. It’s a great strategy game and time killer. I wish that the tips when you log in were longer, can’t finish reading before the game loads. I find the game entertaining and my tips for improving the game would be to have the ability to keep drafted players in the minors longer before having to sign them to a large contract, I let a lot of 2nd and 3rd round picks go. Also would like it to be easier to change a player’s position. Download the game you will not be disappointed

If you are looking for a game that you can spend hours being a GM. Look no further the game is a lot of fun and you do not need to spend any money. If you make good trades and the right decisions, you can go all the way. You do not actually play the baseball games but it’s perfect the way it is. great job creating this one.

Can’t say enough great things about this game. This is my new drug!! Please add an option to drop players to free up FA and extension $$$$$. In RL MLB teams are able to do this. Wish training points were easier to obtain or items were cheaper. Love the fact that there are zero adds and that you can play offline without internet!

When I first saw this game, I thought it was just an ordinary baseball game like all the others but this one is different it’s kind of like the show because you get different game modes that you get to play on you get to customize your characters and there’s a lot of different things about this game than the others. even though you don’t get to actually play with the players to hit, it’s still my best favorite baseball game.

This was already great when I sunk a bunch of hours into it a few years ago, but I have come back and it’s still being updated and it gets better and better and better. The perfect level of detail where you see your decisions mattering and you become invested in your fantasy team. Can’t thank the developers enough for putting out something this comprehensive for free without ads. Buy something in the Shop to show your support!

I've recently gotten back into enjoying baseball now that I have a brother in law who watched the cardinals. This is helping me understand more of the ins and outs of baseball as a fan. Plus it's addicting to keep getting wins!