I am not sure where the negative reviews are stemming from. LiteralClub cultivates an incredible community of book lovers which serves to better curate highlights, comments, and suggestions. The founders are full independent and care about what they are making. Sure, Goodreads is made by Amazon and has the firepower to churn out features but that ends up becoming extremely noisy. Many times, less is more.
If Goodreads is your Amazon or Barnes and Nobles book store, Literal feels like the small locally-owned book shop. The experience is different because it feels more intimate and focused on the human connection.
If you care to support independent creators and well thought out product development, this is it.