Icing on the Cake Reviews

by MLTDG

My review vanished mysteriously so I decided to try playing this game to see if it has improved at all. Not that anyone actually reads these reviews anyway; the people playing and rating this game certainly aren't.
To my surprise, it has. The visuals AND the controls, my two main gripes with the game, have been improved. For one, the cakes actually look like what they're suppose to. The turntable's speed can now be adjusted to be slower for precision work, or faster for quick smoothing. And the piping bag now has crosshairs and a two-second delay before it starts icing the cake, so you can get it into position before piping for extra precision. But that's where the good stuff ends.
For the perfectionistic gamer, it's virtually, if not literally, impossible to get a perfect 100% on any cake that isn't pre-iced. No matter how careful I am, I can never get a score over 95%. The game's rating system could be a bit more forgiving.
Also, the ads. At first, they weren't bad, but after three levels, I started getting forced video ads. The game already has banner ads and optional ads, so why are the forced video ads necessary?
Overall, this game is better than it was before. However, that just means that the game is actually worthy of a one-star rating (as opposed to "zero stars if I could").

by Horsegirl1094

To start oof this game is really fun! I like how your able to adjust the speed of the cake. And it gives you a 2 second start before the icing goes on the cake the perfect amount of time to put your icing on the right place. That’s all the good things about this game.

The bad things, are is when you start finishing putting icing on the top it immediately goes the the smoother with is soooooooooooooo annoying!!!!!!!! The other thing is that is mixes colors that wasn’t even near or touched together. For example, when you smoothing it out for some reason the color that was at the top happens to be mixed with the color on the bottom. Witch doesn’t make any sense when I tested it by, having a space in the middle between them, when I smoothed it out some reason it got mixed together. Another reason is, you could never get a 100 unless ur just smoothing the cake! But it’s so annoying when you take your time on putting icing smoothing it out let me tell you....... YOU WON’T GET A 100!!!!!! I’ve been reading these comments and it looks like these people are to lazy to read these comment and fix these problems? Well they ever fix it? Probably not. This game should be rated 2 stars to be honest. If it improved these problems I would change my rating but for now it’s still saying the same. Sorry that’s on you for not reading people’s comments and fixing these problems.

by Allthenicknamesaretakenghgj

Okay what I like about this is it’s pretty fun! I’m kind of disappointed though. Once you finish a level and click next you get a ad. I understand they need to make money but come on. Seriously there are some levels were you just smooth it out and then once you finish that you get a ad. It’s SUPER annoying. I want to give IcingontheCake a better rating but I can’t this is just not good. There’s just to many ads. Also I don’t think you should call smoothing a cake a level. It’s called “icing on the cake” not “smoothing on the cake” The levels are pretty quick so if your getting a ad every level it’s super annoying also I have made them perfect and have NEVER gotten a 100%. The smoothing isn’t the best because if I get the lines perfect it will smear over the line. Also I’ve been playing this game for a level and I can’t even put on sprinkles or anything? I think I could find a better game then this. It just doesn’t make sense to put a 15 or 20 second long ad after completing a 5 second level. Once and a while you should have a add not every second. I want to like this game but it’s hard to like it. It’s not that hard to stop putting ads in the game every second. I don’t recommend IcingontheCake to anybody.

by Grghjity

Now I saw on this ad that these levels were actually challenging and the kid was ENJOYING it. A lot of people probably like this so no offense this is just my opinion. Something really annoying is the ads!! One pops up every single time you finish a level! It really started to bug me and it’s why I deleted the game, but that isn’t the only reason. The game is about decorating a cake, yeah? It looks fun in the ad but trust me, the levels (to me) are so easy! Come on! Who would want to do these easy levels when you could be playing something more challenging or difficult?! NO ONE. Or at least not me. I hope lion games sees this and if they do make the levels harder! No offense, but I know you can come up with a more original, fun and creative game! You can do better than this, and I know you can! All of your games aren’t as fun as I saw on your ads, but you can surely come with an awesome game! (Once again, no offense was meant to come of this review.) With all of this being said, all I want is a more original game from this developer. Thanks for reading if you will lion games. 😏

by Princess Sasha Bari

The main reason I was attracted to this game was because I’m a cake person/decorator. It was really fun and addicting at the beginning, but it began to be a bit monotonous as the levels got higher bc I was still doing the same thing...and when the game thinks you have iced it enough it switches tools. That’s annoying, I think you should be able to switch tools when ur ready and also be able to switch the icing tips out (shapes) and sizes. Also I didn’t like that it shows like tiered cakes and wedding cakes in the description but you never actually get to reach that until maybe level 1,000...I’m currently on level 70 and haven’t seen it. Also I don’t like that you can only see decorations added and your cakes that have already been done if you select “DECORATE 4 PERFECTION” I think you should have the option to add decorations or different designs if desired. (Whether it be through In-app purchases or by watching tons of ads; or by making the cakes worth dollars instead of stars and building up your money to get different cake designs, icing tips, and sizes.

by Mylittleponyfan😜

I like this game. It’s very relaxing and satisfying. But it would be even more fun if you could bake the cake and then put the icing on it. I know the game is called “Icing On The Cake”, but I would be a tad bit more happy if you could follow a recipe and bake the cake. The levels are a bit repetitive, but they are fun if you can find the good out of it. And it would be awesome if you could do a battle of some sort competing against other players, and whoever finished the cake the best (or in the least amount of time), they would win and get a reward of some sort. Like coins to get new spatulas to ice their cakes with. And when you press the “undo” button, it completely resets your whole cake. So can you fix that? Also there is a little bit more ads than there should be, so please fix that as well. So developer reading this, please make these changes and I will certainly give your game a five star review. Thanks for reading and have a good one :)

P.S. this game is recommended by me, because the concept and graphics are good :)

by Lydia-TheEpicBassist

I love the concept of this game. It’s easy and entertaining. The things I find frustrating about it is when you smooth out the cake the colors end up in places they shouldn’t be anywhere near. The controls are difficult when you’re trying to figure out how to put the icing on top of the cake and it ends up going everywhere. The timing for when you move to another section on the cake is bad. It renders weird when you go from the top section to the bottom. Your icing ends up getting messed up because you can’t control the bag of icing at all. I also think there could be different speeds the cake turns at so you can get used to the controls. The background colors are bland as well. I’d also like to mention I got 100 levels in before I turned the sound on and it was absolutely horrific. It’s like if you had a phobia of icing cake that’s what would play in your head. Should have some silly girly baking music for sure! I’m sure this game is still in the works and I hope some of my feedback will. Help. There should be special or hard levels to unlock different spatulas or icing colors. The game should be individualized. Would buy a full version if it were more fun and did not involve micro transactions.

by Tha Anonymous Truth

Please read this before downloading this game.
My review will be straight to the point, this is not what the ads I have seen show. When I got IcingontheCake I was expecting a fun cake decorating game where you make different kind of cakes following a template, frost and decorate them. This is not really what I got. It’s a game where you see a boring simple cake with only frosting and do that. When you open IcingontheCake you see a fancy wedding cake with decorations and fabulous frosting. Also this game is infinite, as in it goes on forever and you don’t even get a new cake each time, cakes repeat them selves. The only customization is you decide how fast the cake rotates. After a few days of having this on my device I got bored and am probably deleting it soon. It’s not glitchy but it is kind of rigged. For example, when you are frosting your cake it stops letting you frost even if the cake is not fully iced, then fills the blank spots with a random color. So if you are planing on downloading this game looking for a game to have on your device for a few days before rage quitting this is the game for you, if you are looking for a more creative app, go somewhere else.
The Anonymous truth

by I Rate Apps With Honesty

This game is okay, but there are a few problems that annoy me a lot.
The first one is that the game thinks IT knows when you’re done, it will automatically switch to the smoother. It’s annoys the hell out of me because I wasn’t done. Just because IcingontheCake think I’m done, doesn’t mean I am.
The second problem goes with the first one. Once the game assumes I’m done, I’ll start smoothing. It’s annoying, but what’s worse is that it will substitute the area that wasn’t iced with a completely different color. For example: If I’m trying to ice the bottom with a neon pink, it’ll be fine. But once I get to the top of the cake (the last part I have to do, which is when the game cuts me off) icing it with green, the smoother comes out and then I get pink in the spots where the game made me miss! I get a low percent because the colors are getting substituted with a completely different color!
Another problem is that you give me a picture to copy, but how am I supposed to copy the picture you’re if the lines in the picture are perfect, while you cut me off icing, out different colors, and then blend the lines together? I’m trying to get perfect lines like the picture you’re shows, but when you blend the colors together, it’s impossible.
This game needs an update fixing these problems because they’re annoying as hell and I’m tired of dealing with them.

by Kittin 100%

I really like this game ! It’s sooooo fun and satisfying! The pixels are good and the colors are soo bright and pretty! 😁 I do really like the game , but there are a few bugs. To start out with, sometimes the levels seem to repeat itself and that’s kinda annoying...... also sometimes the frosting just smeers together without even getting anywhere close and when I do a good job frosting it, it still smeers.😒 an other thing is that there is a V.I.P level that you have to watch an add for but it’s just the same exact thing that you would do if you didn’t watch the add!!!😤that’s about all of my complaints. ( if you think there are too many adds turn on airport mode and turn of WiFi 👌) I do have some ideas 💡 that could make the game better 🙃 . First of all, maybe you could have more than just frosting and smoothing out. Like maybe be able to do your own design like put frosting poofs on it a sprinkles and cake toppers!🧁and maybe come up with new tools because, the ones that are given are kinda odd looking. 😂 well I still like it and I think it’s super fun and you should get it!!!!
😀😀😀- ✌️✌️✌️

by Pofneke

I like the game I think it’s really fun in my opinion, but there are a few things to start with the constant ADS when you start a new level there always an ad and thats REALLY annoying and makes the player not want to play the game with constantly getting interrupted, and the ads are really… odd😳 but that’s not the point- and second, the levels are getting re over used which makes the game more un appealing to new players or players in general and then there’s like this “vip” thing (totally not a regular icing on the cake it’s totally vip🥺😎) where you have to watch an ad for it and it’s a waste of time cause the “vip” only has like 3 colors and it doesn’t make it any different- and you know what is messed the ad creator are getting money OKAY NOT THE POINT AGAIN BUTTTT- really kinda a waste of time so- oh ye did I tell y’all it’s IMPOSSIBLE to get to 100- no? Well they made the game rigged and mushed the colors together BUT THE MOST ANNOYING PART IS

TO MANY GOD DAM BUGS

fix ur game pls-

by _______<_____>

Ok, first off, this is a very good game and I love playing it. But it is unrealistic at times. I will be smoothing out icing, and see that I missed a spot. And in that spot is a color I didn’t even put there. If this was a real cake, the color next to the missed spot would spread into it, not a random other color that was placed on the cake. Another annoying thing about it is I am always getting two stars, even for cakes that should be three stars. And some cakes that I get three stars on, I should get two stars. But it’s always whacked up and doesn’t give a proper scoring in my opinion. One last annoying thing about it is, the levels repeat. I am on level 184, and old levels are just repeating. There is no new levels. And three times now, I’ve had the same level repeat it’s self two times in a row. So please make more NEW levels. Stop repeating old ones, because the game is getting kind of boring. Other then that I think it is a great app.

by GIGI 🎬

I love this game! It’s fun and It entertains me when I’m bored. It also helps with anxiety. However, there are a few problems. First, when you try to click where you want your icing to go, it puts it above it. Because of this, you have to aim lower and you never really know exactly where to aim so your icing gets all over the place. Secondly, when it thinks you are done icing the cake, it automatically switches your utensils to the spatula thing for spreading. This is extremely annoying because you can’t switch back so icing ends up being mixed and colors are where they aren’t supposed to be. Lastly, colors end up being where they aren’t supposed to be! (Yes I know I repeated myself). For whatever reason, colorsI end up on the other end of the cake where I didn’t even place the color! This gets so frustrating cuz no matter what I do, the cake will never be the way the sample pic is. Other than that, the game is addictive.

by UnicoronGatcha

Hi your game is SO amazing I play it everyday and it helps me calm down!!
But there are some things you need to fix and that leads me to the first one: I hate it when the color mixes when you are smoothing out your cake!! It’s soooooo irritating and makes me angry, like I put the icing on perfectly and then they all mix, then it’s suddenly my fault so then the game says it was not a match like WHAT???!!! It’s like I can never do the PERFECT cake where it’s exactly like the pic!! Anyways the second is that when I’m smoothing out the cake it automatically goes to where it shows you the match page EVEN IF IM NOT DONE WITH SMOOTHING IT OUT!!! I RAGE when that happens! Now my last one is the special cake where you have to watch an ad to do, it was a HUGE cake I really wanted to do so I pressed the ad so I could make the cake and it was a long ad. After I watched the ad, not only did it show another long ad but it also did not let me ice the cake😤😡 I was ANGRY. I get that’s how y’all make money but you should not trick people! So everyone don’t click it it’s a waste of precious time!!

by Roblox_Lover❤️❗️

Ok, so let’s start off with the good things. First, this game is very satisfying, and I love putting the icing on the cake(Hence the name “Icing on the cake,”) and the VIP levels can be rlly nice too. It’s like you’re trying so hard to perfect your cake! But now let’s move on to the annoying things. First, the ads. It doesn’t rlly bother me most of the time bc I’m used to it bc of games like Artist life and My Angela, (games are not mine,) but the thing that rlly annoys me is that I’m icing the cake and I’m not done getting all the icing, and it switches me to smoothing. And then the game has the nerve to give me a 70 or 80%, because a line or stroke of the wrong color, suddenly appears in the wrong spot! It’s especially annoying when I mess up with the wrong color and I try to change it, but I get switched to smoothing. Lastly, it’s not much of a problem but when I have to make the icing do up and down like it’s flowing kind of? I can’t do it. It’s way to hard for me. But that’s just one of my own problems. Overall those are the only bugs you could try to fix. Other than that, this game is pretty good!

by Weewoo<3

honestly, I love this game. I find it really satisfying, actually. but there are small, frustrating things that I really don’t like and I don’t find satisfying at all. so basically, let me talk about this first. I was reading the reviews and so a lot of people were explaining how when you put the icing on the cake it doesn’t place on the right spot. I don’t have a problem with it because there is a circle and I’m pretty sure that actually tells you where exactly to start icing the cake, so that isn’t a problem at all for me. but the frustrating thing about IcingontheCake is that when I’m icing the cake I’m usually not done yet, it’s as if I’m being timed to put down all the frosting because it automatically takes me into the smoothing part after I’m not even halfway done icing my cake. and it’s the same thing with the smoothing, I’m not nearly finished smoothing all of the cake. it just bothers me so much even when there is just the tiniest bit of frosting not smoothed out onto the cake. it also affects my percentages and overall how my cake turns out. so I ask that you would please, please try to fix this. I would greatly appreciate it. but other than that I think IcingontheCake is amazing so keep going! <3

by Pay_up999

I love IcingontheCake ! I had got it and never stopped playing. It’s really annoying because there is SO MANY ADDS and every time I click something there is an add. Sometimes the adds are fun because you don’t have to buy games and you can have every popular game. I would definitely play more but again TO. MANY. ADDS. Like HoW maNy TimeS CaN yUO wAtCh A mAn bE kILleD bY a BeAr?!? I got IcingontheCake because it was in so many adds. Plus I was so tired of it asking for me to buy it. If you can’t help the adds than that’s fine but if you can then CAN YOU PLEASE TAKE THEM AWAY?!?! Anyway, i was reading horse girls review and I agree, you should give us time and when we want to smooth it. And you could have a 3 layer cake but still the bottom color gets mixed with the top! How is that possible? The only time I get 100% is if all I have to do is smooth it. That’s so boring.

by Clownraven1704

Tbh I think this game is fun but they’re are way to many adds once you but the icing on and smooth it out you hit finish and there an ADD!!!! It just makes me mad! It’s also annoying because when you put the colors not even near each other they blend in a it takes percentage away from what you would have !!!

A couple more things before I go !
When the colors are completely separated from each other they still blend but I. Different spots for example I made a cake on this game and the icing on the top was pink and the icing on the bottom was white some how I smoothed it out and Pink which was on the top of the cake went all the way to the bottom of the cake and smeared!!!!! I hope this helped you and will give you a description about IcingontheCake - Raven

by Lucy's Review

Ok so the game is fun but once you play at least to level 92 the levels start repeating and it’s so annoying also there are soooo many ads every 1 or 2 levels there is an ad please make it like every 5 or 6 levels also you should ad this feature to design your own cake and connect with your friends to see if they can match your cake and it’s kind of boring all you do is put icing on a cake then smooth it out and you don’t win any prize except a rating of stars from a computer also you should add money when you finish your cake depending how it looks and you would build a bakery where you get money from costumers and you place your cake on a display and when you connect with your friends they can buy your cake

It’s a lot but it can make the game more interesting and fun

Cool game but not the best

by YOURTRUSTYFRIEND

Nice app. Satisfying, easy, and most importantly...fun! It’s a great game to play when you are board. My entire family has it, and we all really love it! There are levels, and some days, those are fun to beat. But you can also not do the levels and be creative in your own way. Since I’m a very artsy person, that is what I love most about IcingontheCake . It is seriously enjoyable, and probably my most used app. If I absolutely had to file a complaint, it would be about the adds. But you all have to understand that’s how game companies make money! Every app has them. And certain apps aren’t worth those adds, I get it, but this is. You miss 100% of the shots you don’t take, so at least try it. If you click download and don’t enjoy it, then just delete it. Personally, I would find it hard to not like IcingontheCake, but to each his own. If you do like it, give it five stars and write a good review! The people who made IcingontheCake deserve it! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️